Middletown, NY — Rental Investment Analysis

🟡MODERATEaverage returns

Cap Rate

4.1%

Below average

Monthly Cash Flow

-$822

After all expenses

Price-to-Rent

14.4

Investor-friendly

DSCR

0.63

Fails

📊 Key Metrics

Median Home Price
$417,664
Average Rent (3BR)
$2,430/mo
Price-to-Rent Ratio
14.4(good)
1% Rule
0.58%(fails — need 1%+)
Cash-on-Cash Return
-10.2%
Vacancy Rate
8.0%

📈 Market Strength

Assumptions Used

20% down, 7.000000000000001% rate, 30yr, 8% vacancy, 10% maintenance

Customize these numbers →

🏘️ Best Zip Codes in Middletown for Investors

10940
Cap Rate: 4.4%Cash Flow: -$635/mo$391,115
10941
Cap Rate: 3.7%Cash Flow: -$1,009/mo$444,214

All Zip Codes in Middletown

ZipCap RateCash FlowHome PriceRent (3BR)DSCR
109404.4%-$635$391,115$2,440/mo0.69
109413.7%-$1,009$444,214$2,420/mo0.57